Career Path > NRC
Environmentalist vs Nuclear Power
shovelheadred:
A letter to the editor in a widely read magazine stated that he was tired of hearing and reading that individuals calling themselves "environmentalists" were opposed to the use of nuclear power to generate electricity in the US. The writer said that anyone who opposed nuclear power was in effect choosing brownouts and power failures and was an obvious anti-environmentalist since many people's lives depend on a relatively constant flow of electricity (hospitals, drug storage, food preservation). The author concluded that of all the present energy method to supply mass power grids, nuclear power was the cleanest and safest means presently available in the US. " The question we must answer is : Do you agree or disagree with this author's position? Why or why not? Areas such as alternate means of power generation, pollution factors-especially global warming, waste storage, possibility of accidents, and health concerns are all fair game for this.....
....OK Sportsfans..I know you have an opinion on this....red
Marlin:
Yes I do agree with the author. Looking at environmental impact over the fuel cycle of a power source it tends to favor nuclear power provided we solve the long term storage of high level waste. The dams on the Columbia generated very cheap power for a awhile but in the process destroyed a billion dollar salmon fishing industry. Wind power has a great promise but then what about the noise and physical threats over many acres to birds and other wildlife. Wind power seems better suited to small scale generation such as mansions in Tennessee ;D .
Self proclaimed environmentalists may be sincere but ill informed as it is difficult to buck the conventional wisdom of a movement in general. Some previously hard core environmentalists do favor nuclear power, even some who opposed it in the 70's and 80's ( http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/04/14/AR2006041401209_pf.html ). The anti nuclear attitude is not as prevalent as it once was, at least not from rational environmentalists. Whether it is politics or the environment we have a far left element that does not seem to think for itself. We need more leftists and environmentalists like Camella who do think for themselves and talk to us poor heathens that do not agree with them.
SloGlo:
--- Quote from: ShovelHeadRed on Feb 28, 2007, 11:03 ---The author concluded that of all the present energy method to supply mass power grids, nuclear power was the cleanest and safest means presently available in the US. " The question we must answer is : Do you agree or disagree with this author's position? Why or why not?
--- End quote ---
are ya freeking serious? do i agree that nukes are the cleanest 'n safest means presently availablein the us? hail yes! why? cause my livelyhood depends on them? cause i grew up breathing coal fired smog? cause alla moving water is effectively dammed 'n put to use? caws solar is available 1/2 da time ona good day? caws wind power depends on whether da wind blows, 'n whether ted kennedy must look at it? yes. yes. yes. yes. yes.
Charles U Farley:
--- Quote from: SloGlo on Mar 01, 2007, 09:46 ---are ya freeking serious? do i agree that nukes are the cleanest 'n safest means presently availablein the us? hail yes! why? cause my livelyhood depends on them? cause i grew up breathing coal fired smog? cause alla moving water is effectively dammed 'n put to use? caws solar is available 1/2 da time ona good day? caws wind power depends on whether da wind blows, 'n whether ted kennedy must look at it? yes. yes. yes. yes. yes.
--- End quote ---
SloGlo, I like your posts, I really do. But, dammit, you give me a headache trying to translate it to english. After so many glasses of scotch, this time of night, I am having difficulties. ;)
SloGlo:
--- Quote from: Charles U Farley on Mar 01, 2007, 11:31 ---SloGlo, I like your posts, I really do. But, dammit, you give me a headache trying to translate it to english. After so many glasses of scotch, this time of night, I am having difficulties. ;)
--- End quote ---
hay! try reeding out lowd.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
Go to full version