I thought the whole idea was to make a 10th Anniversary logo??
No, it's a
new logo. I clearly stated that it was a new logo "in celebration" of our 10th year in business. I then stated that if we only get crappy logos, we 'might' only use it for one year. I'm happy with the submissions, and I think we can replace our current guy with one of the finalists.
The bottom 3 won't be considered for a replacement logo, as they are too different from our current logo. Our current logo has 10 years of brand recognition, we can't throw that away. When people look at the new logo, they have to 'see' the old logo.
I might use the bottom three submissions for other purposes, such as future bobbleheads, or aids in specific parts of the site, like the study section. We could 'add them to the family', and give Bob some brothers, or sons. Hmmmmm.....