But the training is not the same...ask an electrician a yesterday-today chemistry problem or a mechanic to calculate max power if the RO decides to just start shimming out at X power and you'll see what I mean.
Along with echoing Derek's words, I'll add that by the time an enlisted nuke becomes a supervisor (EWS/EDPO), both of those questions are fair game. You're also leaving out EOOW qualifications at prototype where officers find themselves being trained (after their Officer NPS) how to be an EOOW by an enlisted EOOW. On a Submarine, an enlisted EWS will "sit in the box" while the EOOW tours the plant. Is there a huge knowledge difference at that point? How many JO's and DH's do you know that can still work Calc I/II/DiffEQ problems after being away from college/NPS for five years?
When you are enlisted, you are on the Seaman to Master Chief program.
I'm not sure what this means. Sea Story: I had a young MM3(SU) arrive at my boat. After a few people actally did their job (e.g., meet/greet, interview, review service record), we found his SAT scores were better than most officers' scores. He was off to the Naval Academy that next year. So, yes...if a command doesn't do their job and is only concerned about getting the young MM3 (SU) into coveralls to paint the bilge, then they'll miss an opportunity to retain someone that would otherwise "6 and out" because he/she is bored.
Since I promoted to E-8 and then beyond O-3E, I've done a fairly significant amount of time on "both sides of the fence". For the people that are 18 and find themselves lacking in the maturity and academic prowess of their MIT college bound friends, I'll say "go Enlisted...do SOMETHING and figure out what you want in life!" For the people that are 18 and have SAT/ACT scores in the top quartile I'll ask: "why do you need us crusty guys/gals on Nukeworker to help you launch your career?" For the ET2(SS) that thinks he's smarter than every other person in the world (e.g., "I don't need a college degree...that's all crap") I don't say anything, I just watch Darwin sort him out.
I do not like these "enlisted" versus "officer" threads. How do you obtain a commission? How do you obtain an "enlistment contract?". (Newbies should go Google and read the history of and differences of those paths). Then, Google the different type of officer specialties: URL, EDO, LDO, Staff, etc, etc. I've seen ENG DH's swap over to ED because they hated the "ship driving" part of their job, but loved the nuclear engineering. I've seen Nuclear enlisted people get a commission and spend 20 years in the Naval Aviation community. There are NO absolutes with an enlisted versus officer career...other than this: find something YOU like to do and give it 110%. If you're not sure, MY best advice (another $0.25 for the pot here) is this: get out of your rural, hometown deadend and let the Navy help you finish growing up. If you haven't been preparing for an officer program for 12-24 months (or you don't have the high school GPA) than it probably won't happen...right away. Do what works for you...and then do it better than anyone else. If you find yourself stagnating, then you're in the wrong place...regardless of your rank and seniority!!! I'll save the "being promoted to incompetence" rant for another day.
