I will give you a good example of a union that fits the needs of people that work only part time, have to travel to difficult locations, each location is different and requires a wide range of skills, SAG and IATSE movie workers- pay is high, retirement is fantastic, entry level electrician is $30.00 an hour and so on.. unions are what you make of them.. Oh and dont forget baseball and foot ball- the players union HP technician is a defined skill/craft/trade. Some of us forget that the line of definintion is blurred because of non-union issues and we tend to wander into rad eng, ALARA, etc which in reality is outside of the craft but associated with it. RCT as defined and used by DOE is an ideal description of the HP Tech craft. Collective bargaining organizations for a well defined craft is an advantage for that craft- not an advantage for individuals that may or may not work below standards, wish to work out side of the craft if requested, those that have other means of retirement income, seek management advantage, like to use personal connections to get more than their fellow craft, use their advanced skills or connections to belittle other in the craft, seek to move to management, wish to advance a political idea to "get rid of unions", and so on... If I were a company owner concerned about the most profit I could get.. I would go non-union, its that simple. I can keep wages lower, not offer as much in benefits, pay people different rates that do the same work- devious you say -NO ITS BUSINESS! If I was a company board member in it for the long haul- well beyond my life time and had many employees... I would go union- products tend to be better quality, training is easily accomplished, I can predict costs well into the future because I know the rates paid to workers are standardized, management has to only deal with one individual in general (the union) about work conditions.. I tend to think that HP techs are more like the movie workers union- limited amount of people, unique skills and so on.. this is an IDEAL situation to get a whole lots more pay-face it- no HPS and 20% of the electric power in the US has some problems-big time! But as long as individuals say no to the unions- pay will stay about the same.. Oh and in reality pay has only gone up about 2.3% per year in 27 years.. I was making $18.00 an hour with RAD in 1979... well below the cost of living increases. (assuming $29/hr) The 6%/year rate for 8 years dont sound right maybe if you went from jr decon to srhp. Thats a 48% increase in pay in 8 years. wow!