NukeWorker Forum

News and Discussions => Site News => Topic started by: Rennhack on Dec 29, 2008, 07:45

Title: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Dec 29, 2008, 07:45
In honor of our 10 year Anniversary, we are having a logo contest. 

Here are the finalists, which is your favorite?

(http://www.nukeworker.com/forum/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=16775.0;attach=2575;image)


Here is a link to the contest:

http://logotournament.com/contests/NukeWorker.com (http://logotournament.com/contests/NukeWorker.com)
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Dec 29, 2008, 08:26
Just to be clear, I'm not looking for you guys to enter the contest.  I'm more interested in your feedback on the logo's that other people create.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: NJ on Dec 30, 2008, 12:24
Mike, Just to get this straight...we are just voting on the logos but you are not asking for our Nukeworkers to design an update to our Nukeman?  Is this contest for Logo Tournament and we as Nukeworkers cannot design our own logo and enter without becoming a Logo Tournament member?  I've seen the design quality of our Nukeworkers on the walls of the best containments for years and think we should start at home and see what we've got to offer. What do others think? :-\
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Dec 30, 2008, 09:21
If you want to register at logo tournament and compete, you are welcome to do so.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Camella Black on Dec 30, 2008, 12:18
So far the pickings are slim. I actually like the current logo with the #10 added (which was not accepted) better than the two submitted designs. I would encourage those of you out there that are great at creating graphics to enter the contest.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: NJ on Dec 30, 2008, 12:22
Not too many of us have paypal accounts ::) Camella I agree with you..we should start at home.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Dec 30, 2008, 05:40
Honestly, none of the artwork submitted yet will be accepted, I just didn't want to throw everything in the trash, and discourage them.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: thenukeman on Dec 30, 2008, 09:32
I hate to say it, but I agree with Camella on this one.  I am glad Rennhack is not using any of the ones now because they all suck with the exception of the discarded 10 one that Camella and I think is the best.  The gas mask really sucked!!!!!  LOL
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Dec 31, 2008, 03:04
Depending on what we get for a finished product, we may just use it to only celebrate our 10 year Anniversary.  However, if we find one we really like, we might just upgrade.

Attached below is one of the samples.

The contest runs for 14 days, and I'm told that most of the activity in in the last 2 days.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Dec 31, 2008, 06:42
I think this one is great!
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: thenukeman on Dec 31, 2008, 07:14
Yes , I agree, This is the best so far.  The offerings got a whole lot better today than yesterday!!!   On a scale of 1 to 10 Yesterdays Offerings were a 2.  Todays are getting there.  I give them a 9!!!!  Can add the 10 in there for this year and keep him is my vote.   Maybe we can have a running Poll which we can change our vote if we like a better offering!!
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Jan 01, 2009, 01:04
Maybe we can have a running Poll which we can change our vote if we like a better offering!!

I expect there to be over a hundred entries, we are at 18 right now.  Like I said, most of the action is in the last 2 days.  But it is important to rank them every few hours, and give each picture feedback.

So for the next 10 days, please look at the entries every few hours, and give me your feedback.  Refer to them by the # below the picture, the current 1st place image is #17.  Any feed back we can give each image is important.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: HydroDave63 on Jan 01, 2009, 06:13
Since I'll never ever use PayPal, I'll exhibit my humble creation here. The idea is, subtle changes along the same existing theme, to compliment the original and carry it forward into the future. The cash drifting off gives a sense of motion, somewhat like the dry ice fumes from mad scientist beakers in the movies.


http://www.nukeworker.com/pictures/displayimage-lasthits-11067-1.html (http://www.nukeworker.com/pictures/displayimage-lasthits-11067-1.html)
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: thenukeman on Jan 01, 2009, 09:49
In Reality I like Yours best Dave.  But I think The best pick overall is 17. I move yours up to number 2 Dave.  Too many people may not see the humor in it or the reality.  Sorry good effort!!  Try Again!! LOL
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: SloGlo on Jan 01, 2009, 12:16

http://www.nukeworker.com/pictures/displayimage-548-0.html (http://www.nukeworker.com/pictures/displayimage-548-0.html)

lol!  grate wurk hydrodave63.  karma two yinz.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Camella Black on Jan 01, 2009, 01:06
I love #17. I also like #15.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Lorrie Henson on Jan 01, 2009, 05:42
I also LOVE #17!!  It looks more 'natural' in the facial features than the others. 
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: G-reg on Jan 02, 2009, 05:51
#18 gets my vote currently.  I like the attachment it keeps with the current logo - sort of an evolution/progression feel, vice a wholesale "throw everything out and start over with a new one".  And as cheeky as it may sound, I even like its color scheme.

 - Greg
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: thenukeman on Jan 02, 2009, 10:34
I agree with Rennhack, A black Treifoil is almost a most because most places use it,  Maybe Nukeworker.com below his feet.  A more muscled up version maybe we can see what it looks like.  17 Still is the best!!
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Gamecock on Jan 03, 2009, 08:24
I like #31.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Lorrie Henson on Jan 03, 2009, 08:39
#17 is still my favorite.  Although, maybe have the nukeworker logo below his feet.  How about his right hand on his right hip... as though he's a superhero.  With his hand in a fist, he looks like he's mad.  I don't care for the other version where he has his hand in an A-OK.

But, I do prefer the lighter green can of #17.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: dinutt on Jan 03, 2009, 11:05
 8) #17 gets my vote for sure best overall !!
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Jan 03, 2009, 11:25
The 2 new ones, #31 and #32 are very good too.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Jan 03, 2009, 11:33
I appreciate the feedback.  I AM passing it on to the designers, and it is helping us to get a better logo.  Thank you.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: dinutt on Jan 03, 2009, 02:19
 :D ok now I like #32 looks like it appears to have some energy/fun /in charge look about it Huh?
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: HydroDave63 on Jan 03, 2009, 02:23
But not nearly as blue and traditional as the entry to the left ;)
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: thenukeman on Jan 03, 2009, 05:01
Number 34 looks best then 32.  31 Just doesn't look right.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: HydroDave63 on Jan 03, 2009, 05:29
Number 34 looks best then 32.  31 Just doesn't look right.

31 and 32 look like naughty naughty Manga...
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Lorrie Henson on Jan 03, 2009, 05:49
#34 is the best one yet, with the logo under the feet!  Still something needs to be done with his right hand IMHO.

#31 and #32 just look wrong.  32 looks like a karate kid and 31 looks like a child 'thrusting' himself.  Just wrong IMHO.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: thenukeman on Jan 03, 2009, 08:00
I now  know whats wrong with 31.  It either looks like my 8 year old Daughter Playing dress up looking in the mirror or a metrosexual since this is suppose to be a somewhat masculine figure.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: HydroDave63 on Jan 04, 2009, 06:14
Another reason for sticking with a presentable, business-compatible minor change from what we have today would be the Über-professional Nukeworker image.

Going back through the distant mists of time (2002) when ye olde Nukeworker lifers were naming said mascot...

http://www.nukeworker.com/forum/index.php/topic,840.msg1338.html#msg1338 (http://www.nukeworker.com/forum/index.php/topic,840.msg1338.html#msg1338)
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: SloGlo on Jan 04, 2009, 08:31
butt wood da michelin mann git changed?
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Jan 04, 2009, 10:23
You can rest easy, if we don't fiond something we are in love with, we won't change.  Another option, is tthat we only use the new logo for one year, to celebrate our 10 years in business.  Or just have some stickers and shirts made... who knows.

My original vision was just a refresh on our current logo.  Like what UPS did.

(http://nathantmoore.com/wp-content/uploads/2007/06/ups.jpg)

I got cought up in looking at the cool little nukeworkers guys they were making.  I'll steer the designers back on track.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Jan 04, 2009, 10:38
This is my latest message to the designers:
Quote
NukeWorker Logo Rebranding

People recognize our logo. It is the first visual interface to our company. When it comes to changes to that logo, it is essentially a change to how our customers initially interface visually with our.
We want to update the brand without starting from scratch.
A few years ago, UPS decided to update their logo. Instead of the older, flat, 2-color logo, they went with a more contemporary logo with a 3D gradient. The old logo is shown on the left; the new, on the right. (Link below)

http://nathantmoore.com/wp-content/uploads/2007/06/ups.jpg

We want to maintain the basic foundational layout of our current logo while using design details to modernize it. The recognizability cannot be lost in the new logo. We want to give it more energy - with a “Web 2.0” feel. We want this rebranding to stay consistent with our old logo.

Consistency is the most important thing to consider in this re-branding. Our company look and logo can be updated without sacrificing the integrity of our well-established brand.  We want to ease your customers into our new brand, not shock them into it.  Please recognize the establishment of our brand.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Jan 04, 2009, 10:52
butt wood da michelin mann git changed?
UPS dis, AT&T did...
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: thenukeman on Jan 04, 2009, 12:53
35 Best so Far. The old Nukeworker Image kind of bland.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Lorrie Henson on Jan 04, 2009, 12:55
#35 is my favorite by far!   I would be more apt to 'shop' at this site if this logo was on merchandise.  I think it is absolutely GREAT.  

I'm not loving any of the 10th anniversary versions.  If I HAD to choose one of them, it would be #33, I guess.  
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Lorrie Henson on Jan 04, 2009, 12:59
Will we all get free bumper stickers with the new logo on it?  Or a mug? Or t-shirt??  I know, I know.. wishful thinking... LOL

 :P   ;)   ;D
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: deltarho on Jan 05, 2009, 08:55
I always thought it odd that the logo guy was manhandling a miniature 55 gallon drum of RAM; it almost looks like a Capri Sun without a straw (can you tell I have 6 kids?) His GI Joe Kung-Fu grip is squeezing it almost to the same point that Popeye gets his spinach can before it busts open and sends a stream of spinach to his awaiting gullet.

If the logo was for the navy, it's a no brainer that he should be holding a foxtail instead of the can...maybe with a guy in the background hanging upside down from a pipe with HP tape. ;)

For this site, perhaps he holds a radiac in position to monitor a sitting barrel, instead.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: RDTroja on Jan 05, 2009, 09:06
Been 'off' for a couple of weeks and just got back... (yes, I am aware some of you think 'off' is my normal state)

I have to agree with HoneyComb. Almost all of the submissions are way too cartoonish, many (particularly those by beesoul) are on the childish side. I never was a fan of anime. If the choices don't radically improve, I vote for 'None of the Above." Change is not good unless it is good change. Why am I experiencing a very strong deja-vu right now?
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Jan 05, 2009, 10:29
If the logo was for the navy
For this site, perhaps he holds a radiac in position to monitor a sitting barrel, instead.
This site is comprised of a VERY wide cross section of everything nuclear.  NRC, CEO's, Recruiters, Operators, HP's, Millrights, Electricians, Maint, Deconers, Laborers, Engineers, Technicians, Supervisors, Foreman, Managers.... you get the idea.

Not all nukeworkers were in the navy, and not all of them hold a 'radiac'.  I too had a problem with what I thought a nukeworker was when I first started this site.  But I learned.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Jan 05, 2009, 10:34
I have to agree with HoneyComb. Almost all of the submissions are way too cartoonish, many (particularly those by beesoul) are on the childish side. I never was a fan of anime. If the choices don't radically improve, I vote for 'None of the Above." Change is not good unless it is good change. Why am I experiencing a very strong deja-vu right now?

And 'None of the Above' IS an option.  At least for our site and logo.  I still have to pick a winner, and give the money away.  And I'd like to get something for my money.  The designers only make what we tell them to make.  Perhaps I have been steering them in the wrong direction.

The other problem:  It's hard to improve upon perfection.

IF we see a new design that just talks to us, and tells us that it is the new face of NukeWorker, we'll use it.  If nothing talks to us, we are not going to 'change for the sake of change'.

I'd like to think that the Suites are smarter than that.  (You know, that CEO guy).

--------------

It's still very important that we comment on each designers latest creation, so that we can steer them in the right direction.  They can't read our mind.  We have to tell them what is good, and what we don't like.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Lorrie Henson on Jan 05, 2009, 10:59
#46 is ok, but I still prefer #35.... there's just something about the 'attitude' in #35 that I like.

The girl ones are kinda cute... but not right for this site, since this is a male dominated business.  Have NO idea why she's on ice skates though.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Camella Black on Jan 05, 2009, 01:03
I love the nukeworker guy, but my mind has been wandering towards something more like a firefighter emblem or a ships insignia. A combination of tools of the trade combined to make a logo representing all nukeworkers.

Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Jan 05, 2009, 01:50
A combination of tools of the trade combined to make a logo representing all nukeworkers.

The problem with that is that the tools of the trade are too diverse.  But everyone has to dress up once in a while.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: thenukeman on Jan 05, 2009, 08:10
Ok, I am hearing everyone and seeing the designs,  I noticed that Disney has over 200 Logo's Registered.  I seen The Rennhack UPS and read the Camella Design.   I then came up with one while looking at the Chemical Corps Emblem I am using for the last few weeks as my Avatar. 

Here it is look at my Avatar,   Have Elementis Regamus Proleium Replaced by Nuclearis Potestatis Praestitius, Which is Nuclear power is Superior. Have NukeWorker.com at the very bottom of the bluefield half.  Remove the stump from the bluefield and add a neutron splitting a Atom representing fission.  In the Yellow Field have A earth in the yellow field representing the earth bathed in the life giving yellow glow of the Fusion reaction of the Sun. The Earth can also represent Clean energy especially when compared to coal and Fossil fuels.  Ask my buddies in Kingston TN about the billion gallons of flyash sludge, Also of course the Tons of Coal mined, compared to Uranium,  Less radioactive released in air etc.  I am not a Artist so maybe someone reading this can whip this up.

Too each his own, I am preordering a Dave Money  Shirt,  A polo Shirt with My emblem on it and a Nukeworker bobble head preferably in the 34 style.   Thanks,
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Camella Black on Jan 06, 2009, 10:57
Ok, I am hearing everyone and seeing the designs,  I noticed that Disney has over 200 Logo's Registered.  I seen The Rennhack UPS and read the Camella Design.   I then came up with one while looking at the Chemical Corps Emblem I am using for the last few weeks as my Avatar. 

Here it is look at my Avatar,   Have Elementis Regamus Proleium Replaced by Nuclearis Potestatis Praestitius, Which is Nuclear power is Superior. Have NukeWorker.com at the very bottom of the bluefield half.  Remove the stump from the bluefield and add a neutron splitting a Atom representing fission.  In the Yellow Field have A earth in the yellow field representing the earth bathed in the life giving yellow glow of the Fusion reaction of the Sun. The Earth can also represent Clean energy especially when compared to coal and Fossil fuels.  Ask my buddies in Kingston TN about the billion gallons of flyash sludge, Also of course the Tons of Coal mined, compared to Uranium,  Less radioactive released in air etc.  I am not a Artist so maybe someone reading this can whip this up.

Too each his own, I am preordering a Dave Money  Shirt,  A polo Shirt with My emblem on it and a Nukeworker bobble head preferably in the 34 style.   Thanks,

I actually like your idea. This is more of what I was thinking of; an emblem that would reflect a more professional look. I can imagine it on letterhead, desk sets, shirts, gym bags, etc. I would also love to have a car decal.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: milo124 on Jan 06, 2009, 04:53
I think number 46 is a good "refresh" of the current logo, and I like the face on #46 (and several others) because it's unbiased as far as gendor. As far as what I don't like (and maybe it's just me) - I've never really understood the "nuke can" in the hand.  I'm not sure how you could change that, but I do know the Nukeworker logo is very recognizable out in the field so I wouldn't change it that much.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: thenukeman on Jan 07, 2009, 08:15
I think just Have Milo apply and declare him the winner!!!!  His is probably what most here would like and be agreeable with.  The Metrosexual Beesoul ones are really Awful in my humble opinion.

OH OH, Just looked and 64 looks good,  Maybe a lighter blue and The word year on the can be changed.   Give him a more V Cut to make him look Tougher.  Make him Taller.   Toughest looking one yet. Not a Metrosexual, LOL
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: deltarho on Jan 08, 2009, 03:41
This site is comprised of a VERY wide cross section of everything nuclear.  NRC, CEO's, Recruiters, Operators, HP's, Millrights, Electricians, Maint, Deconers, Laborers, Engineers, Technicians, Supervisors, Foreman, Managers.... you get the idea.

Not all nukeworkers were in the navy, and not all of them hold a 'radiac'.  I too had a problem with what I thought a nukeworker was when I first started this site.  But I learned.

For the record, my reference about the navy was to be taken as a joke; I'm well aware of the diverse community on this site. This site is responsible for broadening my understanding of the extremely diverse paths that are taken to end up here.

That said, the current logo seems to represent a very narrow population on this site--just as "narrow" as having a figure hold a radiac.  Believe it or not, I was hoping that I would spur others with artistic talent to think outside of the box and consider trying to morph the current logo to something fresher and more current, but yet familiar. I just didn't want to necessarily see a slew of 21st century remakes of the old logo.

The ribbing about my lacking the capacity to have an idea was really closer to the truth than you think.  I rose to my rank in the short time I did because I didn't let my guys think I thought I had the best answer or way to do something--I truly valued and relied on the collective wisdom of my charges, which is why my highest ribbon/medal was a good conduct medal after 18+ years. 

I know, this behavior could warrant a piss test. I didn't come by it honestly; I was "ruined" and set on a course to never be a typical goat locker lifer by a CO that wanted to put a bullet in his FitRep that he was implementing TQL.  His answer was to send me to every TQL train-the-trainer class the navy had to offer. I don't truly know why I was the chosen lucky one, however, I did hear rumors that I was selected because I had a psychology degree and TQL was about making a touchy-feely, kinder, gentler navy.

Afterwards, when solving a problem or trying to set up infrastructure I would throw out an idea of how I saw the situation at the end of the day.  I made sure that it was flawed and generally impacted them in such a ridiculous way that they felt compelled to come up with something that they could live with before I could implement anything. How else do you propose I handle a division of malcontents who greeted me with "welcome to hell and FTN" on the first day I walked into the division office?

The process followed a certain formula:

1) Announce a proposed change, which was generally met with moans, groans, and suppositions--usually concentrated on the current status of my head. For example, I either bumped my head or put it someplace that quite frankly is impossible to do, or I lost my maternal copulating mind.

2) Wait for my geeks to put away their Magic the Gathering Cards or turn off the Ren and Stimpy reruns.

3) Facilitate them screaming at each other about how the other's idea sucked harder than Senior Chief's "because" (which led to increased problem solving and brainstorming)

4) Walk away with the final few ideas that were prioritized and had implementation plans that they would manage and could live with because they had ownership.

5) The players that made things happen that had any positive vibes from the command would get full credit.  If it didn't work out or the upper chain had issues with whatever was implemented, I would take the credit (some would say blame). 

Also, I always got my own coffee.  I remembered what I used to do to the cups when I was on the fetching end of the food chain... :o
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: UncaBuffalo on Jan 08, 2009, 09:20
On the 'beesoul' designs...why's there still an airline coming out of their head?  (they don't have a bubble hood)
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: RDTroja on Jan 08, 2009, 11:15
On the 'beesoul' designs...why's there still an airline coming out of their head?  (they don't have a bubble hood)

I started to wonder the same thing until I realized that the artist had no idea what that hose was in the first place and just assumed we were somehow related to unicorns.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Jan 08, 2009, 12:28
1) Announce a proposed change, which was generally met with moans, groans, and suppositions.

2) Wait for my geeks to put away their Magic the Gathering Cards or turn off the Ren and Stimpy reruns.

3) Facilitate them screaming at each other about how the other's idea sucked harder

4) Walk away with the final few ideas that were prioritized and had implementation plans that they would manage and could live with because they had ownership.

5) The players that made things happen that had any positive vibes from the command would get full credit. 

I believe we are in the 3rd step of that solution.  With time running out.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Jan 08, 2009, 12:29
What do you guys think of #70?
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Marlin on Jan 08, 2009, 12:50
70 would be my pick.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Motown homey on Jan 08, 2009, 12:58
#70 is a good update on the current logo.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Jan 08, 2009, 02:20
I just took another look at #62, and I think it is VERY close.  Please look at #62 again and tell me what you think needs to be changed with that one.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Jan 08, 2009, 02:48
I'm also thinking that if #64 had a gray circle behind it, and the font over top like #62, it might be a winner.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Marlin on Jan 08, 2009, 02:53
Still like 70 better.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: MrHazmat on Jan 08, 2009, 03:09
I like the colors on #70 and the wording, if you could put that on #62 it would look great. The container reminds me of a cooling tower. And if you like add the 10 year.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Atomic Archeologist on Jan 08, 2009, 03:28
I'm also thinking that if #64 had a gray circle behind it, and the font over top like #62, it might be a winner.
Should those changes be installed on #64, I think the whole perspective aspect of #62 would be lost.  #62 is good because of the perspective of the guy to the drum and plastering a logo across him would eliminate the effect. 
#69 & #70 have the same relationship.  I like them better and lean more toward #70.  If the background tone was lightened about three shades, it would work pretty well.
One problem I see with the whole body shot, giving the perspective, is that when that gets shrunk to be put onto items, especially small stuff, it will become visually confusing.  Unless a brilliant color are used and a custom created color at that, ala Westinghouse blue, then the logo will not register with the target audience.  I think the half body works better.   
 However, I think the current logo works very well for these stated reasons.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: ruth13 on Jan 08, 2009, 03:40
I like #63 a little better than #62, because of the location of the text.  I also like the gray circle behind #70 and think his facial expression is a little more professional, and less "cartoonish".
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Jan 08, 2009, 04:00
The latest entry, #71 looks good.

(http://www.nukeworker.com/forum/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=16775.0;attach=2566;image)
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: thenukeman on Jan 08, 2009, 05:18
70 looks best.   Can be made better by Changing the treifoil background to yellow as you usually see. Make ridges on the drum to look more real.  Crunch it in and change font as you suggest.   Next 64 next 73.   Maybe we can all give our top 3 to Give more perspective and point out how bad Beesouls sucks, or maybe it is just me that thinks it is that bad.  Point out the bad by not including them can help too.

1.  70

2.  64

3.  73
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Lorrie Henson on Jan 09, 2009, 11:06
I like a combo if 73 and 63.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Jan 09, 2009, 06:48
Check out #90, It's my favorite today.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: thenukeman on Jan 09, 2009, 07:00
I agree on 90,   The last couple of days has had some good Logo's, Even Beesouls last offerings look good.  I think the last few days will be tough to choose from.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Lorrie Henson on Jan 10, 2009, 09:53
I don't care for #90 at all.. just something about it.. maybe the face.. I don't know.

I like 91 and 92, but I think 61 is still my favorite.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Marlin on Jan 10, 2009, 10:37
I see that 70 was withdrawn, too bad, it was still my favorite but 73 is a good second.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: dinutt on Jan 10, 2009, 02:11
 ;D #90 it is!!  something about all the faces need some changes is it me or do most have girl faces??
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: G-reg on Jan 10, 2009, 02:31
#90 looks really good.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: thenukeman on Jan 10, 2009, 04:06
99 looks like me and most nukeworkers I know!!!!  But still 90 is best.  I do like how the can is held in 99 though.  90 with a 99 can would be best lol. 102 a good improvement on 70.  90 then 102
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Jan 10, 2009, 04:54
Here is a concept a friend of mine suggested.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: deltarho on Jan 10, 2009, 07:36
Here is a concept a friend of mine suggested.

Needs a hyphen between 10 and year==> 10-Year and it's perfect--IMO.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Camella Black on Jan 12, 2009, 12:48
In my humble but professional opinion... 82, 84, 108. I believe that 82, and 84 have a clean look about them. I also like 108 but prefer number 82.



Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: SloGlo on Jan 12, 2009, 04:37
mike,  yer buddy's got a good consept.  a bit busy.  maybe just use da current 'n tag 10 years on two da drum.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: thenukeman on Jan 12, 2009, 05:17
119, 108, 113 Pretty close,  In this order but any of these would be good.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: dinutt on Jan 12, 2009, 05:53
 ;D well #113 looks darn good now #109 the face looks smashed up against the hood eyes bulging too funny ! 90 was good....would you all rather not have the 10 year logo on the choice,as it could go on any of the choices....
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Jan 12, 2009, 08:37
The contest has ended, I have 2 days to award a winner.  Please vote in the poll at the top of the page. 

Here are the finalists, which is your favorite?

(http://www.nukeworker.com/forum/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=16775.0;attach=2575;image)


Here is a link to the contest:

http://logotournament.com/contests/NukeWorker.com (http://logotournament.com/contests/NukeWorker.com)

Note:  Notice that "None of the above" and "the original logo" are not options, because I have to award a winner.  We can decide later what to do with the winning entry.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Atomic Archeologist on Jan 13, 2009, 06:16
I like the one in the middle best.  Unfortunately, it doesn't have a number so I can't vote for it.  There is not a "None" choice on the poll, so I guess my vote cast won't count.  :(
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: RDTroja on Jan 13, 2009, 10:24
I had to laugh when I read Atomic Archeologist's post... it was exactly what I was thinking. I know you have to pick a 'winner' and award the prize, but I don't like any of them as much as what we have.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: UncaBuffalo on Jan 13, 2009, 10:34
One thought: If the vote ended right now (1030 on 13Jan), #61 (full-body logo) would win.  Is that truly an indication that we like #61 best?  Because, actually, a majority (17 to 12) prefer a half-body logo...we just don't agree on which half-body logo...
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: NJ on Jan 13, 2009, 02:43
I thought the whole idea was to make a 10th Anniversary logo?????
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Lorrie Henson on Jan 13, 2009, 02:56
Casted my vote... Thanks Mike for including everyone here and addressing our opinions / advise. 

Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Jan 13, 2009, 02:57
I thought the whole idea was to make a 10th Anniversary logo?????

No, it's a new logo.  I clearly stated that it was a new logo "in celebration" of our 10th year in business.  I then stated that if we only get crappy logos, we 'might' only use it for one year.  I'm happy with the submissions, and I think we can replace our current guy with one of the finalists.

The bottom 3 won't be considered for a replacement logo, as they are too different from our current logo.  Our current logo has 10 years of brand recognition, we can't throw that away.  When people look at the new logo, they have to 'see' the old logo.

I might use the bottom three submissions for other purposes, such as future bobbleheads, or aids in specific parts of the site, like the study section.  We could 'add them to the family', and give Bob some brothers, or sons.  Hmmmmm.....
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: dinutt on Jan 13, 2009, 04:37
 8) I just put my vote in  !!  I Ditto it, Mike thanks for letting us play and have some input good idea!!K+ TO YOU
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Jan 13, 2009, 05:03
Here is a collage of the NukeWorker gang at their family reunion, with all the crazy cousins and weird uncles, even the twins came.

(http://www.nukeworker.com/forum/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=16775.0;attach=2578;image)
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Jan 13, 2009, 11:08
I had the guy alter #108 a little.  Here is the final.

(http://www.nukeworker.com/forum/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=16775.0;attach=2580;image)
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Nuclear NASCAR on Jan 14, 2009, 12:06
I like the wave action in the name.  I believe Bob would be proud.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Smart People on Jan 14, 2009, 09:16
Very nice! Congrats to the artist.
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Carolina Jethro on Jan 14, 2009, 10:11
I like the way he smiles while in a respirator... just like all happy Nukeworkers!
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Atomic Archeologist on Jan 14, 2009, 12:44
That's cuz' they took his picture on Doubletime Sunday Extended Work Hours WTL!!!!!,... 8)
He's looks pretty good to be an ex-Rad Services employee! 
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: thenukeman on Jan 14, 2009, 09:37
Aw yes, The best product besides Nukeworker, I seen on the logo contests was Phuk Beer, beer with a story!!  Aw Yes the possibilities having this at a bar. It just sells it self.  The worst was the Lice Sisters!!
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: alphadude on Jan 18, 2009, 08:23
so im not the only one who sees the logo drinking Nuke beer??? 
Title: Re: NukeWorker logo contest
Post by: Rennhack on Jan 24, 2009, 01:18
Well, here it is, The Evolution of The NukeWorker Logo.  From birth in 1999 to it's 10 year Aniv in 2009.

(http://www.nukeworker.com/forum/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=16775.0;attach=2598;image)