I was a Section Adviser for class 9050 and 9101 ETs at NFAS. I called them the Alphas and the Omegas--the beginning and the end. After a sailor was found stuck and passed out under the closed back gate in Orlando trying to sneak in because he was under age, I had the wonderful distinction of having one of mine incriminated with him. As I interviewed my guy, he admitted it, and I asked him whether he was with any others. When it was all said and done, 13 between the two sections were indicted for underage drinking and one 22 year old was found to be contributing to the delinquency of the minors--he was "helping" them out buying the booze, renting a hotel room, confiscating keys, and playing babysitter so that nobody would get hurt.
I was in a pickle; I always told the guys that I would allow them to be stupid and make mistakes, however they would get no mercy for lying, cheating, or stealing. Every one of my guys when confronted told the truth when asked whether they were underage drinking. I never told them whether someone else fingered them. I asked each one of my students, one by one, even the ones not implicated by the others. Only the ones who everyone else said was involved admitted they were drinking. Some who weren't drinking told me that they heard rumors, but because they were not there, did not want to speculate--which I totally agree with--NO GOSSIPING!
I came up with a recourse that the Captain, who later became at least a two star, supported; it allowed everyone save the 22 year old to continue with their training, but on probation. The 22 year old went into 30-day treatment and would be reinstated into the program if he successfully completed 1 year of after care.
This event was THE silver bullet. I do not believe the grace and mercy shown will be repeated because of the emphasis placed on NOT drinking underage--regardless of one's integrity. In fact, the word was put out afterward that any future occurrences will not be tolerated, that the command was using the event as a teachable moment, and that the executioner's hand was still at the lever for the affected students, despite what rumors any students may have heard.